The Pig Butchering Scam: How It Works and Top Ways to Protect Yourself

How Long-Term Manipulation and Easy Access to your Personal Information Makes You a Target

Nov 08, 2024

The term “Pig Butchering" may sound strange, but it describes one of the most dangerous and growing scam techniques online today.

Originating in China and now spreading across the globe, this scam preys on people’s trust, using long-term manipulation to eventually drain your bank account. Whether you’re a seasoned privacy advocate or someone just starting to understand how scammers operate, it’s helpful to be aware of how this scam works and the steps you can take to protect yourself from becoming the next victim.

Welcome to another issue of Secrets of Privacy where we discuss internet privacy related topics and provide practical tips to immediately enhance your privacy.

If you’re reading this but haven’t yet signed up, join the Secrets of Privacy community for free and get our newsletter delivered to your inbox by subscribing here 👇. Upgrade to a paid subscription for less than $0.25 per day.

What is Pig Butchering?

The phrase “pig butchering” is a metaphor scammers use to describe their technique. Much like fattening a pig before slaughter, the scammer "fattens" the victim over time—through grooming and psychological manipulation—before executing the scam and draining the victim's financial resources.

Here's how it typically works:

1. Initial Contact: The scammer reaches out via social media, dating apps, messaging platforms, or even text messages. They often pose as friendly, professional individuals—sometimes under the guise of being romantically interested or offering an enticing business opportunity.

2. Building Trust: Once contact is made, the scammer invests time in cultivating a relationship. They may chat for weeks or even months, patiently gaining the victim’s trust. Unlike quick money-grab schemes, this is a slow and methodical process that makes the victim feel emotionally connected to the scammer.

3. The Hook: After establishing trust, the scammer introduces an investment opportunity, usually involving cryptocurrency, foreign exchange (Forex) trading, or some other high-yield, too-good-to-be-true deal. They often present fake success stories and fabricated screenshots of massive profits to entice the victim.

4. Fattening the Pig: The victim, believing they are being let in on a special opportunity, makes small initial investments, which, according to the scammer’s reports, appear to yield impressive returns. The scammer encourages the victim to invest more over time, convincing them that the more they invest, the greater the reward.

5. The Butchering: Once the victim is fully invested, emotionally and financially, the scammer either blocks them, disappears, or finds a reason the victim cannot access their funds (e.g., claiming there's a need for additional fees or taxes to release the money). By this point, the victim has often invested a significant portion of their savings, and they’re left with nothing.

Why Is Pig Butchering So Effective?

The strength of this scam lies first and foremost in its psychological manipulation. Scammers invest a significant amount of time into building trust, often creating a highly emotional or romantic connection with the victim. Victims may not even realize they are being scammed until it’s too late because the scammer becomes an integral part of their life. It feels personal, not transactional, which is why people let their guard down.

The other reason the Pig Butchering scam is so dangerous is the use of readily available personal information. With the increasing volume of personal data accessible online, scammers can tailor their approach to each victim, making the scam far more convincing and effective. Here’s how easy access to your personal details amplifies the threat:

1. Crafting the Perfect Persona

Scammers can easily gather details about you from social media profiles, public forums, and other online sources. With information like your profession, interests, relationship status, and even your recent activities, they can build a highly convincing fake identity that mirrors your lifestyle. This makes them appear more trustworthy and relatable, which is essential for the long grooming process involved in Pig Butchering.

For example, if you frequently post about your interest in investing or cryptocurrency, the scammer might present themselves as a successful crypto trader, making their eventual “investment opportunity” seem more believable.

2. Targeting Emotional Vulnerabilities

By mining your social media profiles, scammers can also identify emotional triggers. They may learn about a recent breakup, job loss, or financial troubles, which they can exploit to gain your trust more quickly. They might offer emotional support during a tough time, making you feel understood and cared for, which increases the likelihood that you’ll fall for their eventual pitch.

The more personal information a scammer has, the easier it is to play on your emotions, which is at the heart of Pig Butchering scams.

3. Bypassing Initial Suspicion

When someone knows small but significant details about your life, it lowers your guard. A scammer might casually mention things about your recent vacation, your hometown, or a shared interest, all gleaned from your online presence. This knowledge gives the illusion of authenticity and shared experience, helping scammers sidestep any initial doubts you may have.

Additionally, if the scammer uses personal details that seem benign (like mentioning a favorite hobby), it creates a false sense of security, making you more open to engaging with them for the long haul.

4. Amplifying Financial Targeting

If scammers can piece together information about your career or financial situation, they can fine-tune the scale of their scam. For instance, knowing whether you have a higher-paying job, own property, or have spoken about investments online allows them to adjust the amount they ask for in their “investment opportunity,” ensuring it’s within your financial range but still high enough to be lucrative for them.

The scammer might also use this information to present more sophisticated financial opportunities, appearing credible and knowledgeable about your specific interests.

5. Creating a Custom Manipulation Strategy

Each victim is different, and easy access to personal information allows scammers to tailor their manipulation techniques accordingly. For example, they may adjust their approach based on your relationship status, your communication style, or your emotional tone. This flexibility makes it much harder to recognize red flags because the scam feels personalized, not mass-produced.

Share Secrets of Privacy

Common Pig Butchering Methods

Pig butchering scammers employ several sophisticated tactics to lure and manipulate their victims. We touched on these in a general sense above. Here are some of the most common methods they use, discussed in greater detail:

Initial Contact

“Accidental" messages: Scammers often initiate contact by sending seemingly misdirected texts or messages, hoping the recipient will respond.
Dating apps and social media: They create fake profiles on dating platforms or social networks to connect with potential victims.
Group chats: Victims may be added to group chats discussing investments, where other members are actually scammers.

Building Trust

Long-term engagement: Scammers invest significant time in building relationships with victims, often over several months.
Fake personas: They create elaborate fake identities, often using stolen or AI-generated photos.
Showing interest: Scammers express care and concern for the victim's well-being, often discussing mundane topics like meals.

Investment Pitch

Gradual introduction: The topic of investments is introduced slowly after trust has been established.
Fake success stories: Scammers share doctored screenshots or images of their supposed investment successes.
Pressure tactics: They use emotional manipulation to push victims into investing more money.

Maintaining the Scam

Fake investment platforms: Victims are directed to fraudulent websites or apps that mimic legitimate investment platforms.
False profits: Initially, victims may see fake profits or even be allowed to withdraw small amounts to build confidence.
Escalating investments: Scammers continually pressure victims to invest more, often encouraging them to take out loans or liquidate assets.

Exploitation and Exit

Fabricated obstacles: When victims try to withdraw funds, scammers invent taxes, fees, or other issues to extract more money.
Taunting and disappearing: Once the scam is revealed, fraudsters may mock their victims before cutting off all contact.

By understanding these tactics, individuals can better protect themselves from falling victim to pig butchering scams. Always be skeptical of unsolicited contacts, verify the legitimacy of investment opportunities, and never send money to people you haven't sufficiently verified. In the past, we’d say you shouldn’t trust anyone you haven’t met in person, but that’s not practical in our digital centric world.

AI scams are here and getting more sophisticated. One of the best things you can do to protect yourself is to remove your personal information from Google and the data broker sites. That starves the scammers of vital information, making you a much harder target. You can DIY, or pay a reasonable fee to DeleteMe to do it for you. Sign up today and get 20% off using our affiliate link here. We’ve used DeleteMe for almost five years and love it for the peace of mind. It’s also a huge time saver.

How to Protect Yourself

Here are some steps you can take to avoid falling victim to the Pig Butchering scam:

1. Be Wary of Unsolicited Messages: Scammers often initiate contact out of the blue. If someone you don’t know reaches out with friendly banter or a business opportunity, be suspicious. Avoid sharing personal details with people you meet online until you’ve verified their identity.

2. Limit Personal Information Sharing: Scammers often use personal details to appear more credible. Limit how much you share on social media, dating apps, and online platforms. Make sure your privacy settings are secure and avoid engaging with unknown profiles.

3. Don’t Invest Based on Emotional Pressure: No matter how persuasive or successful the person appears to be, avoid making investment decisions based on emotional pressure. If they’re offering something that sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

4. Verify Investment Opportunities: Do thorough research on any investment opportunity. Check for reviews, investigate the platform or business, and avoid using unfamiliar apps or services for transferring money, especially cryptocurrency. It’s important to know whether the investment platform is legitimate and regulated.

5. Trust Your Instincts: If something feels off, it probably is. If the person you're talking to asks for money or investments and tries to rush you into decisions, be cautious. Scammers thrive on urgency and emotional manipulation.

6. Verify identities: Consider using reverse image searches and other online tools to verify the authenticity of online personas.

7. Educate yourself: Stay informed about the latest scam techniques and warning signs. The good news is you’re already doing this by subscribing to our newsletter.

8. Implement two-factor authentication: This adds an extra layer of security to your online accounts and makes it harder for Bad Actors to drain your accounts or take control.

Real-Life Examples

The impact of pig butchering scams can be devastating, as illustrated by these real-life cases:

1. The IT Professional: An Indian IT professional working in Philadelphia lost over $450,000 to a scammer who used deepfake videos and advanced scripting to gain her trust. The scammer convinced her to invest in fraudulent cryptocurrency platforms, leaving her with significant debt. (source)

2. The Nurse: A 37-year-old Malaysian nurse working in Singapore lost over $270,000 to a scammer posing as a 34-year-old interior designer. Feeling lonely due to COVID-19 travel restrictions, she was convinced to invest increasing amounts of money, funded by bank loans, selling her car, and even taking out a mortgage on her house. (source)

3. The Family Man: A 52-year-old man from the San Francisco Bay Area fell victim to a scammer posing as "Jessica" on WhatsApp. The scammer built trust by discussing personal stories and showing interest in his life before introducing a fraudulent cryptocurrency investment opportunity. (source)

4. The Illinois Woman: Erika DeMask, a woman from Illinois, lost her life savings of nearly $1 million to a pig butchering scam. She was forced to sell her home and belongings, and now owes money to her bank from a home equity loan. (source)

Final Thoughts: Stay Vigilant, Stay Protected

To sum it up, the Pig Butchering scam is a long, calculated game where scammers take their time to build trust, manipulate emotions, and drain your finances. The more personal information they can access, the easier it is for them to customize their approach and make the scam feel authentic. But by staying cautious, protecting your online privacy, and recognizing the warning signs early, you can become a harder target. Trust your instincts, be mindful of who you interact with online, and always remember—if something feels too good to be true, it probably is.

Thank you for your continued support and trust in us. 🙏

Looking for help with a privacy issue or privacy concern? Chances are we’ve covered it already or will soon. Follow us on X and LinkedIn for updates on this topic and other internet privacy related topics. We’re also now on Rumble and YouTube. Subscribe today to be notified when videos are published.